Approaches to spatial disparities
Speciális kollégium

Neptun code: llln9267i
Seminar leader: Ferenc Gyuris

Overview:
The course aims to provide a multidisciplinary, historically situated overview of the
main approaches, theoretical concepts, and methodologies on spatial inequality,
including a critical evaluation of the potential and constraints of their application in
research practice as well as in regional and urban planning. It will be discussed how
and why spatial inequality became a matter of interest for the academia in the epoch
of 19th -century European Enlightenment, how it was reinterpreted in the classical
Marxist discourse before coming to its heyday in the post-WWII Cold War context in
service of both rival superpowers, and how it gradually faded out under the aegis of
neoliberalism just to be reinvented by leftist researchers after the oil crises and, more
recently, in light of the 2008 global economic crisis. A main goal is to embed all
influential concepts in their historical, geographical, social, political, economic, etc.
contexts. This provides a basis for revealing the main reasons for the continual
emergence of new concepts, as well as their short- and long-term impact on
scientific, political, and public discourses. Great attention is paid to underlying, and
often conflicting and contested, normative notions of social ideals and “the common
good”, resulting in the problematisation (or de-problematisation) of spatial inequality
and its various aspects perceived as the most important.


Topics:

  • The political discourse of spatial disparities
  • The moral statistics approach of the 19th century: illiteracy, immorality and poverty as engines of inequality
  • From classical Marxism to Marxism-Leninism to Stalinism: “uneven development” in capitalism
  • Early Cold War concepts in the US: spatial inequality research in capitalist economies and liberal democracies
  • Neoclassical economics and the hope of automatically diminishing geographical disparities
  • Polarisation theories: it gets worse before it gets better
  • Post-Fordist neoliberal approaches and the world of “winners” and “losers”: spatial polarisation in service of competition and growth
  • Dependency theories: spatial inequality as an outcome of global power asymmetries
  • Neomarxism and “uneven geographical development”: contemporary views on the political economy of spatial disparities
  • Looking for conclusions: what is the moral for geographers and spatial scientists?


Literature:
Gyuris F. 2014. The Political Discourse of Spatial Disparities: Geographical
Inequalities in Science and Propaganda. Springer: Cham. 381 pages. (+PPT slides
with the key points will be provided). Materials will be accessible at Neptun Meet
Street.


Requirements:
1. Processing the readings for every meeting (~20-30 pages per week). The
meetings will focus on critical discussions of the readings. Active and constructive
contribution is expected.
2. Attending at least 7 meetings.
3. Completing a written exam in the last class.

Szerző
Tolnai Gábor